I was at a comedy show the other night, and the comedian made a joke about learning to use I statements in therapy. He described saying to his ex-wife, “I feel that you're being a [insert mean name].”
If you've been in couples therapy before, you've probably heard of the I statement, a tool that encourages first-person communication and discourages blame in difficult conversations by starting sentences with “I” instead of “you.”
The joke was an obvious misuse of the tool, because he immediately turned it into an insult. But we can also misuse it in less obvious ways.
I statements can be helpful insofar as they reorient communication around sharing our personal experience. They allow us and our partners to engage in conversation with the shared goal of understanding each other better, rather than trying to establish who's right or prove a point. It's this shared goal that matters most. The language is one way of reminding ourselves and our partners to maintain an open, respectful stance. It's also possible to use the language while losing sight of the intention behind it, rendering the exercise meaningless.
Staying engaged in collaborative conversation with our partners can be difficult. Our closest relationships have a way of touching our deepest fears and insecurities. It requires us to remember that we're trying to understand each other, even when everything in us is telling us to defend and protect ourselves. (Of course, there are exceptions when we actually do need to defend and protect ourselves.)
The flipside of the I statement might be an internal “it's not about me” statement as we listen to our partners try to articulate what they're feeling. It helps us lower our defenses when our partners take the extra step of explicitly framing their feelings around their own experience. But even when they forget to do so, we can remember that they're telling us something about their experience every time they talk. And they can do the same for us.
(If you recall English class, your teacher might have told you not to start sentences with “I think” because it's already implied that whatever you write is your own thought. It's kind of like that.)
A little grace goes a long way. We can reasonably expect both people in a relationship to say imperfect things at times. When both people take responsibility for upholding the intention of the conversation, they can help each other navigate these inevitable imperfect moments. This creates an experience of being held that can be just as, if not more, bonding and meaningful than the content being discussed.
Approaching our partners with grace in these conversations also allows more room for creativity. As we learn to trust each other's intentions over time, we can speak in ways that feel more natural, without having to worry so much about getting the words exactly right.
Therapy tools aren’t bulletproof hacks to perfect communication. Ultimately, it's up to both the speaker and the listener to maintain respect and seek understanding. It's an active effort, and it's not always easy, especially at first. But when we extend this courtesy to ourselves and our partners, we create more room for connection, understanding, and creativity in our relationships.